Tenant's Rights Library
Rent Withholding and Repair and Deduct in California: A Tenant's Step-by-Step Guide
The exact procedure for each remedy, and the mistakes that defeat them.
California gives tenants two self-help remedies when a landlord will not repair a substandard condition. Repair and deduct under Civil Code section 1942 lets you pay for a repair and subtract the cost from rent, capped at one month's rent and usable twice in any twelve-month period. Rent withholding is a common-law remedy with no dollar cap, but it carries real risk: the landlord will likely serve a three-day notice and file an unlawful detainer, and you will have to prove the breach in court. Both remedies require written notice to the landlord and a reasonable opportunity to repair. Neither is available for damage you caused.
When Can a California Tenant Withhold Rent or Repair and Deduct?
Only when the defect is a substantial breach of habitability standards that materially affects health and safety, you have given the landlord notice, and the landlord has failed to repair within a reasonable time. Cosmetic problems, minor inconvenience, and conditions you caused do not qualify.
Every residential lease in California contains an implied warranty of habitability. Regardless of what the lease says, the landlord must maintain the property to meet minimum health and safety standards. When the landlord fails to do so, these two remedies become available — but both are legally technical, and a tenant who skips a step can lose the protection entirely.
Three conditions must be satisfied before either remedy is available:
- The defect must be substantial. It must materially affect your health and safety, not merely your comfort or the appearance of the unit.
- The landlord must have notice. Written notice is strongly preferred, and for repair and deduct it is effectively required as a practical matter of proof.
- A reasonable time must have passed. What is reasonable depends on the severity of the defect.
What Makes a Rental Unit Legally Uninhabitable in California?
Civil Code section 1941.1 lists the characteristics a dwelling must have to be legally tenantable. A unit substantially lacking any one of them is untenantable. Health and Safety Code section 17920.3 supplies a parallel list of substandard conditions.
| Required | What a Violation Looks Like |
|---|---|
| Weather protection | Effective waterproofing of roof and exterior walls; unbroken windows and doors. Leaking roof, rain intrusion, rotted frames. |
| Plumbing and gas | Functioning gas, water, and sewage facilities in good working order. Sewage backup, chronic blockage, gas leaks. |
| Water supply | Hot and cold running water connected to an approved sewage disposal system. No hot water, intermittent service. |
| Heating | Functioning heating facilities. No heat in one or more rooms; broken furnace; inoperative thermostat. |
| Electrical | Safe and working lighting, wiring, and equipment. Exposed wiring, dead outlets, unsafe fixtures. |
| Sanitation | Grounds and building kept clean and free of debris, filth, rubbish, garbage, rodents, and vermin. Infestation, accumulated garbage. |
| Garbage receptacles | An adequate number of containers in clean condition and good repair. |
| Floors, stairways, railings | Maintained in good repair. Dry rot, holes, missing or loose handrails, collapsing steps. |
| Stove and refrigerator (new for 2026) | A working stove capable of safely generating heat for cooking, and a working refrigerator capable of safely storing food. See AB 628 below. |
Civil Code section 1941.3 separately requires deadbolt locks on main entry doors and operable locking devices on windows and exterior doors.
What Did AB 628 Change for 2026?
Assembly Bill 628, signed October 6, 2025 and effective January 1, 2026, amended Civil Code section 1941.1 to add a working stove and refrigerator to the list of characteristics required for a unit to be tenantable. Failure to provide them is now a habitability breach.
The new subdivisions require a stove maintained in good working order and capable of safely generating heat for cooking purposes, and a refrigerator maintained in good working order and capable of safely storing food. Because these standards now sit inside section 1941.1, a broken landlord-supplied stove or refrigerator is no longer an ordinary maintenance request — it is a breach of the implied warranty of habitability, and it triggers the same remedies as a broken furnace.
AB 628 applies only to tenancies entered into, amended, renewed, or extended on or after January 1, 2026. If your lease predates that date and has not been renewed or amended since, the appliance requirement does not yet apply to your tenancy. Confirm the date of your current lease before relying on this provision.
Three further points on AB 628:
- Recalled appliances. A landlord must repair or replace a stove or refrigerator subject to a manufacturer or public-entity recall within 30 days of receiving notice of the recall. A recalled appliance does not satisfy the standard.
- Tenant-supplied refrigerators. A landlord and tenant may agree at the inception of the tenancy, in writing and with specified lease language, that the tenant will supply and maintain their own refrigerator. There is no equivalent exception for stoves, and a landlord may not condition a tenancy on the tenant supplying a refrigerator.
- Exempt housing. The requirement does not reach permanent supportive housing, single-room occupancy units, units in residential hotels, or dwellings within facilities offering shared or communal kitchens, including assisted living facilities.
The statute also confirms that nothing in the appliance provisions prevents a tenant from using the remedies available under Civil Code section 1942 — which is to say, repair and deduct applies to a broken stove or refrigerator like any other habitability defect.
Which Conditions Do Not Qualify?
Minor reductions in service, cosmetic defects, ordinary inconvenience from repair work, and anything you or your guests or pets caused. Courts have also held that a tenant may not be evicted merely because a water heater is not strapped or anchored to meet the seismic requirement.
How Do I Use the Repair and Deduct Remedy in California?
Notify the landlord in writing of the defect and of your intent to repair and deduct, allow a reasonable time to fix it, hire someone to make the repair, keep the receipt, deduct the cost from your next rent payment, and give the landlord a copy of the invoice with the reduced payment.
Under Civil Code section 1942, a tenant may pay for a repair and deduct that cost from the next month's rent. The statute is narrow, and each requirement matters.
- Give written notice. Notify the landlord or the landlord's agent of the defect and of your intent to deduct the cost of repair from rent unless the landlord performs the repair. Oral notice is legally sufficient, but certified mail with return receipt requested is strongly recommended so you can prove the date and content later.
- Allow a reasonable time. The law presumes 30 days is reasonable. For genuine emergencies — a burst pipe, a broken heater in freezing weather — a reasonable time may be as short as 24 to 48 hours.
- Have the repair performed. Use a qualified contractor where the work calls for one. Keep the invoice, proof of payment, and photographs of the condition before and after.
- Deduct the cost from the next rent payment. Do not withhold more than the actual repair cost.
- Deliver documentation with the reduced rent. Give the landlord a copy of the invoice and a short written explanation identifying the defect, the date of your notice, and the amount deducted.
How Much Can I Deduct?
No more than one month's rent for the repair. If the work costs more than that, repair and deduct will not cover it, and you will need a different approach.
How Often Can I Use Repair and Deduct?
Twice in any twelve-month period. This is the limitation that makes the remedy useful only for discrete, moderate repairs rather than for a landlord who has let an entire unit deteriorate.
The California Supreme Court relied on precisely these constraints — the one-month cap and the frequency limit — when it held in Green v. Superior Court (1974) 10 Cal.3d 616 that the repair-and-deduct statutes are not a tenant's exclusive remedy. Because they are useful only for minor repairs, the court reasoned, the broader implied warranty of habitability must also be available.
How Do I Withhold Rent in California?
Document the defect thoroughly, give the landlord written notice and a reasonable time to repair, then pay a reduced amount reflecting the unit's diminished value — setting aside the withheld portion in a separate account. Expect the landlord to serve a three-day notice and file an eviction.
Rent withholding is more aggressive and considerably riskier than repair and deduct. You stay in the unit and refuse to pay some or all of the rent until repairs are made. There is no dollar cap, but the remedy requires a substantial habitability defect and it will very likely put you in court.
- Document everything first. Dated photographs and video, written complaints, and any code-enforcement report. Build this record before you withhold, not after.
- Give written notice and a reasonable time to repair. Same standard as repair and deduct.
- Request a code-enforcement inspection. An official citation is the single strongest piece of evidence available to most tenants, and it may trigger a statutory presumption discussed below.
- Withhold only a proportional amount. See below.
- Set the withheld money aside. See below.
- Prepare to defend an unlawful detainer. Assume the landlord will file. If served, you generally have 10 court days to file a written response.
How Much Rent Can I Withhold?
Only an amount proportional to your loss of use. If one room of four is unusable because of a leak, a reduction of roughly 25 percent is generally defensible. Withholding the entire rent for a partial defect undermines your credibility with the judge.
Where Should I Keep the Withheld Rent?
In a separate bank or escrow account, untouched. This is not strictly required by statute, but it is strongly recommended: it demonstrates to the court that you had the money and were withholding on principle rather than simply failing to pay.
The distinction matters more than tenants expect. A judge deciding whether a habitability defense is genuine will weigh whether the tenant preserved the funds. A tenant who spent the withheld rent looks like a tenant who could not pay; a tenant who set it aside looks like a tenant asserting a legal right.
Under certain conditions the court may enter a protective order requiring you to deposit rent as it comes due — not the rent already withheld — into court during the case. Money paid in under a protective order is distributed to the parties according to the verdict.
Which Remedy Should I Use?
Repair and deduct suits a single moderate repair you can afford to front. Rent withholding suits serious, ongoing conditions costing more than one month's rent to fix. Withholding carries far greater risk, because it invites an eviction lawsuit you must then win.
| Repair and Deduct | Rent Withholding | |
|---|---|---|
| Source of law | Civil Code § 1942 (statutory) | Implied warranty of habitability (common law) |
| Dollar limit | One month's rent per repair | No cap; must be proportional to loss of use |
| Frequency limit | Twice in any 12 months | None |
| Money out of pocket | Yes — you pay the repair first | No — but set the withheld rent aside |
| Severity required | Dilapidation affecting habitability | Substantial breach materially affecting health and safety |
| Likelihood of eviction suit | Lower | High — expect a 3-day notice |
| Best for | A broken water heater, a failed lock, a single plumbing repair | Persistent infestation, no heat, sewage, multiple serious defects |
What Are My Own Obligations as a Tenant?
Civil Code section 1941.2 requires tenants to keep the premises clean and sanitary, dispose of garbage properly, use plumbing and electrical fixtures correctly, and refrain from damaging the property. Neither remedy is available for a condition you, your guests, or your pets caused.
This is the most common way a tenant's claim collapses. A landlord defending a habitability case will look first for evidence that the tenant caused the condition or made it worse by neglect. Two of the tenant obligations in section 1941.2 do not apply where the landlord has expressly agreed in writing to perform those acts.
What Happens If My Landlord Sues Me for Eviction?
You raise breach of the implied warranty of habitability as an affirmative defense in your written answer. If you prove it, the court reduces the rent to the unit's reasonable rental value in its defective condition, denies the landlord possession, and may order repairs.
If you withhold rent, the landlord will likely serve a three-day notice to pay rent or quit and then file an unlawful detainer. The procedure the court follows is set by Code of Civil Procedure section 1174.2:
- The trial. The judge determines whether a substantial breach occurred.
- The reduction. If a breach is found, the judge sets the reasonable rental value of the unit in its defective condition.
- The order. The judge may order the landlord to make repairs and retain jurisdiction to ensure compliance.
- The outcome. If you pay the reduced amount — generally within five days of judgment — possession is denied to the landlord and you are the prevailing party, entitled to costs and attorney's fees where a statute or your lease provides for them.
Winning is conditional. A tenant who prevails at trial but fails to pay the court-set amount within five days loses possession anyway, and the landlord becomes the prevailing party for purposes of attorney's fees. Plan in advance how you would pay the adjusted rent on five days' notice.
The habitability defense, the case law behind it, and what a court must do at trial are covered in full in our companion guide to the implied warranty of habitability and your eviction defense.
Can My Landlord Retaliate Against Me for Requesting Repairs?
No. Civil Code section 1942.5 prohibits a landlord from raising rent, reducing services, or threatening or bringing an eviction in retaliation for a tenant's repair request or use of these remedies. The statute establishes a presumption covering the 180 days following your protected activity.
Retaliation is a separate affirmative defense from habitability, and the two are frequently raised together. Our guide to defending against a retaliatory eviction covers the presumption, the good-faith requirement, and the evidence needed to prove it.
What If a Code Inspector Has Already Cited My Landlord?
Your position improves substantially. Civil Code section 1942.3 creates a rebuttable presumption that the landlord breached the section 1941.1 standards if cited defects are not corrected within 60 days of the official's written notice.
A related and stronger remedy appears in Civil Code section 1942.4, which bars a landlord from demanding or collecting rent at all where a code-enforcement agency has cited the property, the landlord has failed to correct the conditions within 35 days, and the other statutory conditions are met. A tenant who prevails under section 1942.4 is entitled to reasonable attorney's fees and costs under Code of Civil Procedure section 1174.21.
If no inspection has occurred, requesting one from your city or county code-enforcement department is usually the highest-value action available to you before withholding rent.
What If the Damage Came From a Fire, Flood, or Other Disaster?
Different rules apply. Effective January 1, 2026, Civil Code section 1941.8 imposes a duty on landlords to remove disaster debris and mitigate hazards, and section 1941.9 discharges the obligation to pay rent during a mandatory evacuation.
- Until a local public health agency determines that disaster debris does not contain toxic substances, its presence at the unit is presumed to render the unit untenantable under section 1941.1.
- The landlord must remediate within a reasonable time and follow all cleaning protocols issued by government officials, including using licensed remediation contractors where required.
- The tenancy remains in effect, and the tenant has a right to return at the same rental rate as soon as it is safe and practicable.
- For any period a mandatory evacuation order prevents occupancy, the rent obligation is discharged and prepaid rent must be returned within 10 calendar days after the order lifts.
These provisions were added by Senate Bill 610, chaptered as Chapter 547, Statutes of 2025. Parallel language applies to mobilehomes under Civil Code section 798.64.
What Mistakes Defeat These Remedies?
The most common are withholding before documenting, giving only oral notice, withholding the full rent for a partial defect, spending the withheld money, exceeding the statutory caps, and missing the response deadline after being served.
| Mistake | Consequence |
|---|---|
| Withholding first, documenting later | Conditions arising only after you stopped paying and were served a pay-or-quit notice generally cannot defend the earlier nonpayment |
| Oral notice only | Legally sufficient but unprovable; becomes your word against the landlord's |
| Withholding 100% for a partial defect | Undermines credibility; court may find the withholding unreasonable |
| Spending the withheld rent | Looks like inability to pay rather than assertion of a right; leaves you unable to meet the five-day payment order if you win |
| Deducting more than one month's rent | Exceeds section 1942; the excess is simply unpaid rent |
| Using repair and deduct a third time in 12 months | Outside the statute; the deduction is unpaid rent |
| Missing the 10-court-day response deadline | Default judgment and lockout; the defense is never heard |
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I legally stop paying rent if my landlord will not make repairs in California?
You may withhold rent where the landlord has substantially breached the implied warranty of habitability, you gave notice, and a reasonable time passed without repair. But withholding is not a safe harbor — it invites an unlawful detainer action in which you must prove the breach. Withhold only an amount proportional to your loss of use, set the money aside in a separate account, and document the conditions before you stop paying rather than after.
How long does my landlord have to make repairs in California?
For repair and deduct under Civil Code section 1942, the law presumes 30 days is a reasonable time. Genuine emergencies shorten that substantially — a burst pipe or a broken heater in freezing weather may require action within 24 to 48 hours. If a code-enforcement official has issued a written notice, failure to correct within 60 days creates a rebuttable presumption of breach under Civil Code section 1942.3.
How much can I deduct for repairs from my rent in California?
No more than one month's rent per repair, and you may use the remedy only twice in any twelve-month period. If the repair costs more than one month's rent, repair and deduct will not cover it. Those limits are why the California Supreme Court held in Green v. Superior Court that the statute is not a tenant's exclusive remedy.
Does my landlord have to provide a refrigerator and stove in California?
For tenancies entered into, amended, renewed, or extended on or after January 1, 2026, yes. AB 628 amended Civil Code section 1941.1 to require a working stove capable of safely generating heat for cooking and a working refrigerator capable of safely storing food. A tenant may agree in writing at the start of the tenancy to supply their own refrigerator, but there is no equivalent exception for stoves. Certain housing types are exempt, including single-room occupancy units and dwellings with shared communal kitchens.
Can my landlord evict me for withholding rent?
Your landlord can file an unlawful detainer, and probably will. Whether the eviction succeeds depends on whether you prove the habitability breach. If you do, the court reduces the rent to the unit's reasonable rental value, denies possession, and treats you as the prevailing party — conditioned on your paying the reduced amount, generally within five days of judgment. Separately, Civil Code section 1942.5 prohibits eviction in retaliation for a repair request within 180 days of your protected activity.
Primary Sources for This Guide
- California Eviction Defense Manual (Cal CEB, April 2025), chapters 14 and 15. Published by Continuing Education of the Bar — California.
- California Civil Code: § 1941; § 1941.1; § 1941.2; § 1941.3; § 1942; § 1942.1; § 1942.3; § 1942.4; § 1942.5.
- California Code of Civil Procedure: § 1174.2; § 1174.21.
- California Health and Safety Code § 17920.3, substandard building conditions.
- Assembly Bill 628 (McKinnor, 2025), amending Civil Code § 1941.1; Senate Bill 610 (Pérez, 2025), Chapter 547, adding Civil Code §§ 798.64, 1941.8, and 1941.9.
- Green v. Superior Court (1974) 10 Cal.3d 616; Hinson v. Delis (1972) 26 Cal.App.3d 62; Knight v. Hallsthammar (1981) 29 Cal.3d 46.
- Judicial Council of California Civil Jury Instructions: CACI No. 4320, Affirmative Defense — Implied Warranty of Habitability.
Related Guides in the Tenant's Rights Library
Eviction Defense & Tenant's Rights Rapid Response Phone Line
Monday through Friday, 8:30 a.m. to 6:00 p.m. All calls are confidential.